Oligomerization Of Membrane Proteins Research Articles

An efficient method for detecting membrane protein oligomerization and complex using 05SAR‐PAGE

AbstractOligomerization is an important feature of proteins, which gives a defined quaternary structure to complete the biological functions. Although frequently observed in membrane proteins, characterizing the oligomerization state remains complicated and time‐consuming. In this study, 0.05% (w/v) sarkosyl‐polyacrylamide gel electrophoresis (05SAR‐PAGE) was used to identify the oligomer states of the membrane proteins CpxA, EnvZ, and Ma‐Mscl with high sensitivity. Furthermore, two‐dimensional electrophoresis (05SAR/sodium dodecyl sulfate–PAGE) combined with western blotting and liquid chromatography–tandem mass spectrometry was successfully applied to study the complex of CpxA/OmpA in cell lysate. The results indicated that 05SAR‐PAGE is an efficient, economical, and practical gel method that can be widely used for the identification of membrane protein oligomerization and the analysis of weak protein interactions.

Quantification of membrane protein oligomerization in native-like membrane enviroments by SiMPull-POP (single molecule pulldown-polymeric-nanodisc oligomer photobleaching)

Quantification of membrane protein oligomerization in native-like membrane enviroments by SiMPull-POP (single molecule pulldown-polymeric-nanodisc oligomer photobleaching)

Utility of FRET in studies of membrane protein oligomerization: The concept of the effective dissociation constant

The activity of many membrane receptors is controlled through their lateral association into dimers or higher-order oligomers. Although Förster resonance energy transfer (FRET) measurements have been used extensively to characterize the stability of receptor dimers, the utility of FRET in studies of larger oligomers has been limited. Here we introduce an effective equilibrium dissociation constant that can be extracted from FRET measurements for EphA2, a receptor tyrosine kinase (RTK) known to form active oligomers of heterogeneous distributions in response to its ligand ephrinA1-Fc. The newly introduced effective equilibrium dissociation constant has a well-defined physical meaning and biological significance. It denotes the receptor concentration for which half of the receptors are monomeric and inactive, and the other half are associated into oligomers and are active, irrespective of the exact oligomer size. This work introduces a new dimension to the utility of FRET in studies of membrane receptor association and signaling in the plasma membrane.

Rationalizing the Optimization of Detergents for Membrane Protein Purification.

Membrane protein purification by means of detergents is key to isolating membrane-bound therapeutic targets. The role of the detergent structure in this process, however, is not well understood. Detergents are optimized empirically, leading to failed preparations, and thereby raising costs. Here we evaluate the utility of the hydrophilic-lipophilic balance (HLB) concept, which was introduced by Griffin in 1949, for guiding the optimization of the hydrophobic tail in first-generation, dendritic oligoglycerol detergents ([G1] OGDs). Our findings deliver qualitative HLB guidelines for rationalizing the optimization of detergents. Moreover, [G1] OGDs exhibit strongly delipidating properties, regardless of the structure of the hydrophobic tail, which delivers a methodological enabling step for investigating binding strengths of endogenous lipids and their role for membrane protein oligomerization. Our findings will facilitate the analysis of challenging drug targets in the future.

The dependency of slow CLC-ec1 dimerization kinetics on lipid solvent volume.

Although protein association equilibrium has been vastly studied in water, questions remain about how membrane proteins assemble and operate within the oily solvent environment of the membrane. However, recent developments in the field provide the potential for understanding the molecular basis of these reactions. In particular, our lab has developed approaches for quantifying the equilibrium affinities of membrane protein oligomers in membranes, a physical model for protein association and folding. Using single-molecule photobleaching microscopy, the lab has demonstrated CLC-ec1 participates in a fully reversible, equilibrium dimerization reaction in membranes. Our studies reveal the kinetics of dimerization are slower than most biological reactions taking days to equilibrate at 37 ºC in 2:1 POPE/POPG lipid bilayers. Here, we investigate the molecular basis for the slow kinetics by measuring subunit exchange kinetics in membranes. We hypothesize the dimerization reaction involves a high-energy transition state that requires the formation of a vacuum cavity in between the two subunits inaccessible to the surrounding solvent. We expect measuring the reaction in mixed lipid bilayers that include smaller lipoidal molecules will lead to a reduced cavity volume along the reaction pathway, decreasing the transition state energy barrier, which will be observed by speeding up of the reaction kinetics. To test this, CLC-ec1-Cy3 and CLC-ec1-Cy5 subunit exchange equilibration rates are measured by bulk Förster Resonance Energy Transfer at 37 ºC in 2:1 POPE/POPG while titrating benzene, n-Octyl-β-D-Glucoside, and 2:1 PE/PG lysolipids. In parallel, coarse-grained molecular dynamics simulations are carried out on the same mixed lipid systems to calculate the solvent-inaccessible cavity volumes between subunits as they are separated from 8 to 24 Å. The results from this investigation will provide a quantitative analysis offering insight into why membrane protein complexes are often kinetically trapped in lipid bilayers.

A single-molecule method for measuring fluorophore labeling yields for the study of membrane protein oligomerization in membranes.

Membrane proteins are often observed as higher-order oligomers, and in some cases in multiple stoichiometric forms, raising the question of whether dynamic oligomerization can be linked to modulation of function. To better understand this potential regulatory mechanism, there is an ongoing effort to quantify equilibrium reactions of membrane protein oligomerization directly in membranes. Single-molecule photobleaching analysis is particularly useful for this as it provides a binary readout of fluorophores attached to protein subunits at dilute conditions. However, any quantification of stoichiometry also critically requires knowing the probability that a subunit is fluorescently labeled. Since labeling uncertainty is often unavoidable, we developed an approach to estimate labeling yields using the photobleaching probability distribution of an intrinsic dimeric control. By iterative fitting of an experimental dimeric photobleaching probability distribution to an expected dimer model, we estimate the fluorophore labeling yields and find agreement with direct measurements of labeling of the purified protein by UV-VIS absorbance before reconstitution. Using this labeling prediction, similar estimation methods are applied to determine the dissociation constant of reactive CLC-ec1 dimerization constructs without prior knowledge of the fluorophore labeling yield. Finally, we estimate the operational range of subunit labeling yields that allows for discrimination of monomer and dimer populations across the reactive range of mole fraction densities. Thus, our study maps out a practical method for quantifying fluorophore labeling directly from single-molecule photobleaching data, improving the ability to quantify reactive membrane protein stoichiometry in membranes.

Amphiphilic Co-Solvents Modulate the Structure of Membrane Domains

Biofuels are an increasing part of the sustainable energy picture. This makes it a societal and economic imperative to optimize biofuel production. Mitigating the toxic effects of amphiphilic co-solvents is one way to improve the efficiency of biofuel production. Amphiphiles partition into cellular membranes, leading to membrane thinning, destabilization, loss of membrane potential, and, ultimately, cell death. However, this picture of solvent toxicity misses the disruptive impact of co-solvents on lateral membrane organization, which is increasingly recognized as critical for membrane protein sorting and oligomerization. The alteration or disruption of membrane domains has deleterious effects on cellular processes. In this work, we pursue the hypothesis that membrane lateral organization is disrupted by the presence of co-solvents at concentrations lower than those which lead to full membrane destabilization. The disruption occurs due to an increasing interfacial tension between the co-existing phases, resulting in conformational changes to minimize the interfacial length-to-area ratio. This represents an unrecognized mode of solvent-induced stress and a new target for interventions to improve fermentation yields.

Structural and biochemical insights into His-tag-induced higher-order oligomerization of membrane proteins by cryo-EM and size exclusion chromatography

Structural and functional characterization of proteins as well as the design of targeted drugs heavily rely on recombinant protein expression and purification. The polyhistidine-tag (His-tag) is among the most prominent examples of affinity tags used for the isolation of recombinant proteins from their expression hosts. Short peptide tags are commonly considered not to interfere with the structure of the tagged protein and tag removal is frequently neglected. This study demonstrates the formation of higher-order oligomers based on the example of two His-tagged membrane proteins, the dimeric arginine-agmatine antiporter AdiC and the pentameric light-driven proton pump proteorhodopsin. Size exclusion chromatography revealed the formation of tetrameric AdiC and decameric as well as pentadecameric proteorhodopsin through specific interactions between their His-tags. In addition, single particle cryo-electron microscopy (cryo-EM) allowed structural insights into the three-dimensional arrangement of the higher-order oligomers and the underlying His-tag-mediated interactions. These results reinforce the importance of considering the length and removal of affinity purification tags and illustrate how neglect can lead to potential interference with downstream biophysical or biochemical characterization of the target protein.

Oligomerization of peripheral membrane proteins provides tunable control of cell surface polarity

Asymmetric distributions of peripheral membrane proteins define cell polarity across all kingdoms of life. Non-linear positive feedback on membrane binding is essential to amplify and stabilize these asymmetries, but how specific molecular sources of non-linearity shape polarization dynamics remains poorly understood. Here we show that the ability to oligomerize, which is common to many peripheral membrane proteins, can play a profound role in shaping polarization dynamics in simple feedback circuits. We show that size-dependent binding avidity and mobility of membrane-bound oligomers endow polarity circuits with several key properties. Size-dependent membrane binding avidity confers a form of positive feedback on the accumulation of oligomer subunits. Although insufficient by itself, this sharply reduces the amount of additional feedback required for spontaneous emergence and stable maintenance of polarized states. Size-dependent oligomer mobility makes symmetry breaking and stable polarity more robust with respect to variation in subunit diffusivities and cell sizes, and slows the approach to a final stable spatial distribution, allowing cells to “remember” polarity boundaries imposed by transient external cues. Together, these findings reveal how oligomerization of peripheral membrane proteins can provide powerful and highly tunable sources of non-linear feedback in biochemical circuits that govern cell surface polarity. Given its prevalence and widespread involvement in cell polarity, we speculate that self-oligomerization may have provided an accessible path to evolving simple polarity circuits.

In Vitro Synthesis and Reconstitution Using Mammalian Cell-Free Lysates Enables the Systematic Study of the Regulation of LINC Complex Assembly.

Understanding the structure and structure-function relationships of membrane proteins is a fundamental problem in biomedical research. Given the difficulties inherent to performing mechanistic biochemical and biophysical studies of membrane proteins in vitro, we previously developed a facile HeLa cell-based cell-free expression (CFE) system that enables the efficient reconstitution of full-length (FL) functional inner nuclear membrane Sad1/UNC-84 (SUN) proteins (i.e., SUN1 and SUN2) in supported lipid bilayers. Here, we provide evidence that suggests that the reconstitution of CFE-synthesized FL membrane proteins in supported lipid bilayers occurs primarily through the fusion of endoplasmic reticulum-derived microsomes present within our CFE reactions with our supported lipid bilayers. In addition, we demonstrate the ease with which our synthetic biology platform can be used to investigate the impact of the chemical environment on the ability of CFE-synthesized FL SUN proteins reconstituted in supported lipid bilayers to interact with the luminal domain of the KASH protein nesprin-2. Moreover, we use our platform to study the molecular requirements for the homo- and heterotypic interactions between SUN1 and SUN2. Finally, we show that our platform can be used to simultaneously reconstitute three different CFE-synthesized FL membrane proteins in a single supported lipid bilayer. Overall, these results establish our HeLa cell-based CFE and supported lipid bilayer reconstitution platform as a powerful tool for performing mechanistic dissections of the oligomerization and function of FL membrane proteins in vitro. While our platform is not a substitute for cell-based studies, it does provide important mechanistic insights into the biology of difficult-to-study membrane proteins.

Native Ambient Mass Spectrometry of an Intact Membrane Protein Assembly and Soluble Protein Assemblies Directly from Lens Tissue.

Membrane proteins constitute around two-thirds of therapeutic targets but present a significant challenge for structural analysis due to their low abundance and solubility. Existing methods for structural analysis rely on over-expression and/or purification of the membrane protein, thus removing any links back to actual physiological environment. Here, we demonstrate mass spectrometry analysis of an intact oligomeric membrane protein directly from tissue. Aquaporin-0 exists as a 113 kDa tetramer, with each subunit featuring six transmembrane helices. We report the characterisation of the intact assembly directly from a section of sheep eye lens without sample pre-treatment. Protein identity was confirmed by mass measurement of the tetramer and subunits, together with top-down mass spectrometry, and the spatial distribution was determined by mass spectrometry imaging. Our approach allows simultaneous analysis of soluble protein assemblies in the tissue.

Native Ambient Mass Spectrometry of an Intact Membrane Protein Assembly and Soluble Protein Assemblies Directly from Lens Tissue.

Membrane proteins constitute around two‐thirds of therapeutic targets but present a significant challenge for structural analysis due to their low abundance and solubility. Existing methods for structural analysis rely on over‐expression and/or purification of the membrane protein, thus removing any links back to actual physiological environment. Here, we demonstrate mass spectrometry analysis of an intact oligomeric membrane protein directly from tissue. Aquaporin‐0 exists as a 113 kDa tetramer, with each subunit featuring six transmembrane helices. We report the characterisation of the intact assembly directly from a section of sheep eye lens without sample pre‐treatment. Protein identity was confirmed by mass measurement of the tetramer and subunits, together with top‐down mass spectrometry, and the spatial distribution was determined by mass spectrometry imaging. Our approach allows simultaneous analysis of soluble protein assemblies in the tissue.

Protein engineering and biochemical/biophysical approaches for structural studies of small membrane proteins and their complexes: Application to viroporins

We study the structure and function of small viral membrane proteins, which are expressed in the host and function in cellular membranes. Typically, they are multi‐domain multi‐functional proteins aiding virus adaptation and proliferation. Detailed characterization of the structure‐function relationship of these proteins will help to better understand virus‐host interactions and possibly develop protein inhibitors. However, such characterization is challenging due to the proteins’ small size and dynamic nature. Our focus is on viroporins, namely the Vpu, p7 and E proteins from HIV‐1, HCV, and CoV, respectively. Viroporins form ion‐conducting oligomers in cellular membranes leading to increased membrane permeability affecting ion homeostasis in infected cells. In addition, these proteins have soluble domains involved in interactions with host proteins. Currently, the structures of full‐length viroporins are largely uncharacterized and the information about the mechanism of oligomer formation and inter‐domain communication is very limited. Here, we report our effort to produce and solve the structure of stable viroporin oligomers in lipid environment. We use protein engineering to generate a range of fusion constructs aiming to increase the protein/oligomer size and reduce the conformational heterogeneity, thus making the protein amenable for structural determination by electron microscopy (EM) techniques. We produced, expressed in E. coli and purified, several soluble constructs of Vpu, p7 and E proteins fused at their N‐terminals to maltose binding protein (MBP). Thereafter, we interacted these proteins with lyso lipid mixtures of PC and PG, and their oligomerization was observed by negative staining EM and pulse electron paramagnetic resonance (EPR). We further use size‐exclusion chromatography (SEC) to assess the heterogeneity of viroporin oligomers in lyso PC/PG. Indeed, the protein elution exhibits a relatively broad chromatographic profile, indicating the presence of more than one oligomeric form. We further use SEC to test different protein‐to‐lipid molar ratios and the effect of viroporin inhibitor binding, aiming to shift the equilibrium toward stable functional viroporin oligomers. We will also discuss results from EM studies on these stable oligomers and EPR studies on spin‐labeled viroporin assembly. The progress we made in generating protein constructs and assessing protein oligomerization and stability in lipid provides a great promise for the development of successful methodology to determine the structure of full‐length viroporin. This methodology could also be applicable to other small oligomeric membrane proteins.

In-membrane protein oligomerization as a critical step for membrane pore formation

Oligomerization of membrane proteins into multicomponent units is often critical for their function (or dysfunction). To give an example for all, apoptosis, also known as programmed cell death, is induced at the molecular level by a change in the aggregation behavior of proteins, subsequent formation of protein complexes with a broad distribution of oligomerization numbers, and finally opening of functional pores in the mitochondrial membrane. Despite this knowledge, it is unclear which of these complexes are functional, i.e.

Reconstitution of purified membrane protein dimers in lipid nanodiscs with defined stoichiometry and orientation using a split GFP tether

Many membrane proteins function as dimers or larger oligomers, including transporters, channels, certain signaling receptors, and adhesion molecules. In some cases, the interactions between individual proteins may be weak and/or dependent on specific lipids, such that detergent solubilization used for biochemical and structural studies disrupts functional oligomerization. Solubilized membrane protein oligomers can be captured in lipid nanodiscs, but this is an inefficient process that can produce stoichiometrically and topologically heterogeneous preparations. Here, we describe a technique to obtain purified homogeneous membrane protein dimers in nanodiscs using a split GFP (sGFP) tether. Complementary sGFP tags associate to tether the coexpressed dimers and control both stoichiometry and orientation within the nanodiscs, as assessed by quantitative Western blotting and negative-stain EM. The sGFP tether confers several advantages over other methods: it is highly stable in solution and in SDS-PAGE, which facilitates screening of dimer expression and purification by fluorescence, and also provides a dimer-specific purification handle for use with GFP nanobody–conjugated resin. We used this method to purify a Frizzled-4 homodimer and a Frizzled-4/low-density lipoprotein receptor–related protein 6 heterodimer in nanodiscs. These examples demonstrate the utility and flexibility of this method, which enables subsequent mechanistic molecular and structural studies of membrane protein pairs.

Exploring the trimerization process of a transmembrane helix with an ionizable residue by molecular dynamics simulations: a case study of transmembrane domain 5 of LMP-1

The oligomerization of membrane proteins is an important biological process that plays a critical role in the initialization of membrane protein receptor signaling. Unveiling how transmembrane segments oligomerize is critical for understanding the mechanism of membrane receptor signaling activation. Owing to the complicated membrane environment and the extraordinary dynamic properties of the ionizable residues in the transmembrane segment, it is extremely challenging to thoroughly understand the oligomerization process of the transmembrane domain. In this study, transmembrane domain 5 (TMD5) of latent membrane protein-1 from Epstein-Barr virus was used as a prototype model to investigate the trimerization process of the transmembrane segment with ionizable residues. The trimerization process of TMD5 was rebuilt and investigated via conventional molecular dynamics simulations and constant-pH molecular dynamics simulations. When TMD5s approached each other, the tilting angles of the TMD5 monomer decreased. TMD5s formed stable trimers until two interacting sites (D150s and Q139s) along each transmembrane helix were created to lock the TMD5s. The pKa values of D150 shifted toward neutral states in the membrane environment. When TMD5s were monomers, the pKa shift of D150 was mainly influenced by its microenvironment in the lipid bilayer. When TMD5s were moving close to each other, protein-protein interactions became the main contributing factor for the pKa shift of D150s. Overall, this work elucidates the behavior of the TMD5 helix and the pKa shift of ionizable residue D150 in the process of TMD5 oligomerization. This study may provide insight into the development of agents for targeting the oligomerization of membrane proteins.

Dissecting Role of Charged Residue from Transmembrane Domain 5 of Latent Membrane Protein 1 via In Silico Simulations and Wet-Lab Experiments.

Charged residues are frequently found in the transmembrane segments of membrane proteins, which reside in the hydrophobic bilayer environment. Charged residues are critical for the function of membrane protein. However, studies of their role in protein oligomerization are limited. By taking the fifth transmembrane domain (TMD5) of latent membrane protein 1 from the Epstein-Barr virus as a prototype model, in silico simulations and wet-lab experiments were performed to investigate how the charged states affect transmembrane domain oligomerization. Molecular dynamics (MD) simulations showed that the D150-protonated TMD5 trimer was stable, whereas unprotonated D150 created bends in the helices which distort the trimeric structure. D150 was mutated to asparagine to mimic the protonated D150 in TMD5, and the MD simulations of different D150N TMD5 trimers supported that the protonation state of D150 was critical for the trimerization of TMD5. In silico mutations found that D150N TMD5 preferred to interact with TMD5 to form the heterotrimer (1 D150N TMD5:2 protonated TMD5s) rather than the heterotrimer (2 D150N TMD5s:1 protonated TMD5). D150R TMD5 interacted with TMD5 to form the heterotrimer (1 D150R TMD5:2 protonated TMD5). These in silico results imply that D150N TMD5 and D150R TMD5 peptides may be probes for disrupting TMD5 trimerization, which was supported by the dominant-negative ToxR assay in bacterial membranes. In all, this study elucidates the role of charged residues at the membrane milieu in membrane protein oligomerization and provides insight into the development of oligomerization-regulating peptides for modulating transmembrane domain lateral interactions.

Cardiolipin Selectively Binds to the Interface of VsSemiSWEET and Regulates Its Dimerization.

Lipid-regulated oligomerization of membrane proteins plays a critical role in many cell-transduction pathways. However, molecular details of such processes are often hard to define experimentally. Here we reveal the key role of interfacial cardiolipin in regulating the functional dimerization of VsSemiSWEET (one of the smallest transporters) using molecular dynamics simulations. Four binding sites for cardiolipins are identified by calculating the spatiotemporal density distribution of cardiolipins and the free energy surface. Two types of dimerization modes (i.e., arm-to-body and body-to-body) are observed in the assembly process of VsSemiSWEET protomers. Binding of enough cardiolipin molecules at the dimer interface on the cytoplasmic side is found to be crucial in adjusting the monomer-dimer equilibrium and regulating the formation of functional dimers with proper conformation. Our results provide useful information on the relationship between lipid binding and functional dimerization of VsSemiSWEET and are helpful to understand the molecular mechanism of biological function of sugar transporters.

Determination of G-protein-coupled receptor oligomerization by molecular brightness analyses in single cells.

Oligomerization of membrane proteins has received intense research interest because of their importance in cellular signaling and the large pharmacological and clinical potential this offers. Fluorescence imaging methods are emerging as a valid tool to quantify membrane protein oligomerization at high spatial and temporal resolution. Here, we provide a detailed protocol for an image-based method to determine the number and oligomerization state of fluorescently labeled prototypical G-protein-coupled receptors (GPCRs) on the basis of small out-of-equilibrium fluctuations in fluorescence (i.e., molecular brightness) in single cells. The protocol provides a step-by-step procedure that includes instructions for (i) a flexible labeling strategy for the protein of interest (using fluorescent proteins, small self-labeling tags or bio-orthogonal labeling) and the appropriate controls, (ii) performing temporal and spatial brightness image acquisition on a confocal microscope and (iii) analyzing and interpreting the data, excluding clusters and intensity hot-spots commonly observed in receptor distributions. Although specifically tailored for GPCRs, this protocol can be applied to diverse classes of membrane proteins of interest. The complete protocol can be implemented in 1 month.

Effective production of oligomeric membrane proteins by EarlyBac-insect cell system.

Despite major advances in methodologies for membrane protein production over the last two decades, there remain challenging protein complexes that are technically difficult to yield by conventional recombinant expression methods. A large number of these proteins are multimeric membrane proteins from eukaryotic species, which are required to pass through stringent quality control mechanisms of host cells for proper folding and complex assembly. Here, we describe the development procedure to improve the production efficiency of multi-oligomeric membrane protein complexes in insect cells and recombinant baculovirus, which involves screening of promoters, enhancers, and untranslated regions for expression levels, using calcium homeostasis modulator (CALHM) and N-methyl-d-aspartate receptor (NMDAR) proteins as examples. We demonstrate that our insect cell expression strategy is effective in expression of both multi-homomeric CALHM proteins and multi-heteromeric NMDARs.